YouTube wiped Novara Media – a left-wing news and commentary channel – from its platform, before reversing the move shortly afterwards. Conservatives, already used to Big Tech’s censorship, were not surprised.
“This morning the Novara Media YouTube channel was deleted without warning or explanation,” Novara tweeted on Tuesday.
A statement from Novara Media on our YouTube channel’s deletion. pic.twitter.com/LXRUaIQN1X
— Novara Media (@novaramedia) October 26, 2021
“Novara Media is among the top 50 most watched news and politics channels in the UK,” the statement continued. “We play an important public service role and regularly feature interviews with politicians, human rights campaigners, scientists and activists from around the world. We are regulated by IMPRESS in the UK.”
The channel was reinstated around two hours later, but a massive outcry had already erupted. Leftists, including sitting Labour MPs, were dismayed at what they thought amounted to blatant censorship. “Unaccountable tech giants should not be able to censor regulated journalism,” Novara editor Ash Sarkar tweeted. “It’s that simple.”
This is outrageous by YouTube. Novara Media plays an invaluable role in providing reportage, analysis & commentary of many of the key issues facing our community. It has given a platform to many voices that would otherwise not be heard, especially young people.@novaramediahttps://t.co/PJUH6V9Gek
— John McDonnell MP (@johnmcdonnellMP) October 26, 2021
This is an attack, without warning, on one of UKs premier left wing media orgs. An attack on free speech and a trend to censor left by mainstream media organisations/platforms. I hope that @Google and @YouTube urgently review and reverse this decision. Solidary to @novaramediahttps://t.co/DllArxTrjJ
— Lloyd Russell-Moyle MP🌹🏳️🌈 (@lloyd_rm) October 26, 2021
— Peter Stefanovic (@PeterStefanovi2) October 26, 2021
Yet for those on the right, the news came with a side of irony. Sarkar has mixed views on the existence of so-called “cancel culture,” alternately describing the phenomenon as fictional, an example of social justice in action, “a way to demonise the process of culture changing,” as well as actual censorship of dissenting voices. With her own outlet apparently canceled, right-wingers reminded her that those advocating for censorship will inevitably fall victim to it.
“Big Tech can & WILL censor everyone, irrespective of your socio-political perceptions of moral superiority,” commentator Dominique Samuels wrote.
Google has deleted one of the best and largest left-wing media outlets in the UK. No warning or explanation was provided. Just zapped it out of existence.Congratulations to online censorship advocates: this is the system of repression and arbitrary silencing you created! https://t.co/lLte4g1JfD
— Glenn Greenwald (@ggreenwald) October 26, 2021
— Fish Supper (@baconmadras) October 26, 2021
Social media apps are now under pressure, including by law in some countries, to delete misinformation & hate speech. In many cases, this will look like censorship of left or right wing politics.The media is going to get what they asked for and will complain about it anyway. https://t.co/is6uMa57I8
— Dare Obasanjo (@Carnage4Life) October 26, 2021
YouTube has long been accused of censoring right-wing channels and creators, and the wider tech and social media industry is perceived by many to be biased against conservatives. Yet leftist outlets – some of which proudly supported the censorship of right-wing voices – have found themselves canceled too, suggesting that anti-establishment thought in general is frowned upon by the tech giants.
Throughout the coronavirus pandemic, all major platforms have stepped up their censorship efforts, focusing mostly on so-called “misinformation” surrounding the virus and vaccines. YouTube has banned all “harmful vaccine content” and introduced a “Covid-19 medical misinformation policy,” which sets out a wide range of forbidden topics regarding the coronavirus. The video sharing platform, a subsidiary of Google, has banned two of RT’s German-language channels for supposedly violating this policy, deleted a chart-topping video by anti-Joe Biden rapper Bryson Gray for allegedly peddling “medical misinformation,” and temporarily suspended the account of a sitting US senator for questioning the effectiveness of cloth face masks.
Also on rt.com
US representatives censored after calling transgender ‘1st female four-star’ admiral a man on Twitter
The censorship crackdown is not limited to YouTube. Twitter this week censored two US congressmen for calling transgender Admiral Rachel Levine “a man,” and Facebook – which already heavily restricts so-called “hate speech” and “health-related misinformation” – is facing calls to step up its censorship game from ‘whistleblower’ Frances Haugen and lawmakers supporting her demands to further regulate speech on the platform.
Like this story? Share it with a friend!